What is the correct spelling of towards
towards the dark forest
If a noun is followed by a directly related expression, it is called an apposition. The fact that the grammatically correct handling of such appositions is sometimes not that easy is impressively demonstrated by our latest "Inquired" gnarly.
In the case of directions, the more detailed definition of "direction" can, as far as I know, be appended with genitive or without an article as an apposition: towards the forest or towards the forest.
But what about the inflection if - without an article - an adjective is added? Does it correctly say: "We are going towards the dark forest"; or: "We're going in the direction of the dark forest" - or even: "We're going in the direction of the dark forest"?
Julian von Heyl ,korkturen.de
The Duden grammar states as a basic rule that for appositions with an adjective but without an article word, both congruence and the nominative are correct. In both cases the adjective is strongly inflected.
The form "We are going in the direction of the dark forest" is initially correct, and the nominative is clearly preferred in comparable cases, according to the evidence in the Duden corpus.
When applying the rule of congruence (the apposition shows the same case as the reference word) one must first answer the question in which case »direction« stands here, because the preposition »in« can be used with dative or accusative depending on the context. According to Duden Volume 9, "Correct and Good German", one should distinguish whether the path is still to be taken (directional information and therefore accusative) or whether one is already on the path (location and therefore dative). Accordingly, on the one hand, "We are going towards the dark forest at the next intersection", on the other hand "We have been walking in the direction of the dark forest for half an hour" would be correctly formed sentences. The Duden has, however, taken a step backwards with the formulation "it usually means", describing it rather than being razor-sharp.
Dr. Werner Scholze-Stubenrecht, head of the Duden editorial team
Julian von Heyl on May 29th, 2014 | Comments (2) | Visits: 10035
| Inquired section:|
Even the specialist literature no longer helps? We asked and received a competent answer: The Duden editorial team clarifies grammatical and orthographic doubts about the German language for us. Our tip: You can get quick telephone information from Duden-Sprachberatung.
Thank you for the comments, Mr. Scholze-Stubenrecht!
I only have one question: Couldn't the genitive also be used here ("in the direction of the dark forest")?
The choice of the genitive does not seem completely absurd to me, because in the online edition of the Dudens under "Direction" the following is stated: "towards [...] of the village"(As of June 18, 2019).
Greetings, have a nice day!
Written by Anne on 6/18/19 11:44 AM
2 Julian von Heyl
Of course, "in the direction of the dark forest" is also correct, but it does not correspond to the question about the correct form without "the".
Written by Julian von Heyl on 6/18/19 12:57 PM
Write a comment:
The fields marked with a * must be filled out.
Your email address will not be published!
|For search queries, please use the word search in the top right corner of the box or the Google search field above. The entire website is searched with the custom Google search.|
- Can we move through dark matter
- ACT is nice
- How did your faith affect your parents?
- Affiliate marketing is possible without investment
- How do people become xenophobic nationalists?
- How does Hennessy taste
- Married women in India are sexually frustrated
- What is the new embed function
- What is API and Web Services
- What do you think of junk food
- Should I drink glucose water between workouts?
- How was your new year celebration
- Which films have the best marketing activities
- What do actuaries do
- What is an expat who lives in Yangon
- How can teachers inspire students
- What are the components of cleaning services
- Why shouldn't we drink contaminated water?
- How is trust maintained in a relationship
- What is the Poisson process
- What are the psychological effects on productivity?
- Why is my stepfather feeling uncomfortable
- Do you want to find out
- Do cats remember their kittens?