What is the best Christmas tree stand

Christmas tree stand comparison 2021

The best Christmas tree stand in comparison.

For many, the Christmas spirit only really arises when the Christmas tree is bought, set up and festively decorated. So that the Christmas tree survives the holidays safely and firmly in the living room at home, you need a suitable Christmas tree stand.

Find out in our buying guide which type of Christmas tree stand is particularly easy to use and why not every fir tree base is suitable for outdoor use in the garden or on the terrace. You can see from our comparison table which models are ahead in relevant Christmas tree stand tests.

Christmas tree stand recommendations:

Did you like this Christmas tree stand test or comparison?

Purchase advice for the Christmas tree stand test or comparison 2021

the essentials in brief
  • Christmas tree stands ensure that our Christmas trees survive the festive season safely and firmly in the living room at home. Many stands have a water tank that keeps the tree fresh as long as possible, even in a heated room.
  • A distinction is made between Christmas tree stands based on their technical functionality. In terms of safety and handling, Christmas tree stands with rope tensioning technology are ahead and dominate the German market.
  • For nostalgic reasons, some people prefer special Christmas tree stands that are made of special materials and are now collectible items, such as rotating Christmas tree stands with music boxes.

Every year, just in time for the holidays, it takes its place in our living rooms: the Christmas tree on the Christmas tree ceiling. For the Germans it should be one thing above all else: from real twigs and needles. In 2016, an impressive 62% in a PoSpulse survey said they wanted to buy a real Christmas tree. But it's not done with that. In order to enjoy the fir or spruce for as long as possible and at the same time ensure the necessary security in your own four walls, you need a suitable tree stand.

In our Christmas tree stand comparison 2021, we have compared popular models from different manufacturers for you and tell you what is essential when buying the best Christmas tree stand. We wish you a Merry Christmas!

1. Christmas tree stands have a long tradition

Antique Christmas tree stand

Antique tree stands are particularly popular with collectors. There are, for example, Christmas tree stands with music that can be combined with songs like? Silent Night, Holy Night? Rotate slowly around its own axis. Such Christmas tree stands with music box were first produced in 1873 by the Eckhardt company near Stuttgart. Today these rare collector's items are sold for over a thousand euros on the Internet.

Special stands for the Christmas tree have been around for a long time. As early as the early 17th century, there are first references to wooden Christmas tree stands with which the Christmas tree, which is decorated every year, was held in place. From the middle of the 19th century, heavy cast iron stands were made, which are still known today as part of traditional Christmas decorations.

This one-piece cast variant has long been the predominant type of Christmas tree stand in German living rooms. The models have a recess in the middle, in which the trunk of the fir tree is positioned and fixed with screws.

This changed suddenly in 1990, when the Bavarian farmer Klaus Krinner introduced the first Christmas tree stand with the so-called ? Single rope tensioning technology? brought to market. Krinner himself came up with the revolutionary idea while he was laboriously erecting his own Christmas tree, instead of using screws to lash the Christmas tree into position with just a single wire rope. This was not only much faster, but also ensured that the Christmas tree stood more securely in the stand.

Since this invention, the Christmas tree stand with single-rope tensioning technology has dominated the market. Today the Krinner company estimates that 99% of all Christmas trees in German living rooms operate with this technology. But even if this estimate should be a bit high, Christmas tree stands with rope tensioning technology have significant advantages over traditional stands with screws:

  • safer when standing
  • can be set up by just one person
  • effortless and quick assembly
  • greater scope for trunk thickness
  • lighter weight
  • mostly made of plastic
  • less beautiful optics

2. Different types of Christmas tree stands

In the past, Christmas tree stands were extremely impractical to use and often led to the notorious family disputes over Christmas. Adjusting the Christmas tree in particular was very difficult to realize with the old screw tree stands and it took an eternity until the tree was finally upright.

Fortunately, progress has not stopped at the Christmas tree stand and there are now a number of tree stand systems that are extremely easy to use, even for laypeople. In order to avoid an emergency purchase shortly before the festival, you should, however, think about the right Christmas tree stand in November.

If you are already the proud owner of a tree stand, you should check early on whether the stand is still fully functional. If it turns out that a new purchase is necessary, there is a small purchase advice for Christmas tree stands.

Pay attention to safety when buying a Christmas tree stand When buying a Christmas tree stand, always pay attention to safety seals of approval and, if in doubt, go for quality goods. In addition to the harmlessness of the individual screw and ratchet levers of the Christmas tree stand systems, stability naturally plays a major role when choosing the right tree stand. The decorated Christmas tree must not fall over if it is touched lightly. Fillable Christmas tree stands, as discussed below, have advantages here.

2.1. Christmas tree stand with clamping screws

In the case of the Christmas tree stand with clamping screws, the tree is fixed with a screw system. Usually there are three or four wing screws that have to be screwed into the trunk.

Many people still know this tree stand from their childhood. For precisely these nostalgic reasons, the classic motifs in cast iron and metal optics are currently dominating the trade in screw Christmas tree stands, some of which have an extremely noble effect and go well with classic tree decorations.

It still is such a cast iron Christmas tree stand is not that easy to use. If you want to set up the Christmas tree, you have to crawl awkwardly under the tree with its scratching branches. Screwing the trunk under the tree then also requires a little more effort.

Fixing in the screw tree stand is usually better if the whole family helps and several people hold the tree. And since it can take a long time before the tree is really straight, it helps if the current status of the tree alignment is observed by neutral witnesses, even if this procedure carries a certain risk to the peace of the family at Christmas.

2.2. Christmas tree stand with clamping mechanism

With this Christmas tree stand variant, the tree is attached with the clamping jaws and a foot lever or a crank.

An example of such a Christmas tree stand is the “terra bronce” metal stand from Heibi. The Christmas tree is simply placed in the tube holder and clamped by stepping on the foot pedal. The tree can be detached just as easily. The tree is adjusted with a centering mandrel.

2.3. Christmas tree stand with rope pull technology and water tank

With the rope pull technique, the tree becomes Clamped into a wire rope with clamps via a foot lever. These Christmas tree stands are considered special user-friendly and safe. At the same time, the tree stands also supply the Christmas tree with water.

Tip: If your tree stand is too complicated for you: just take your Christmas tree stand with you when you buy a Christmas tree. Many Christmas tree sellers are happy to help fix the tree. Then simply carry the adjusted tree home with the stand.

Screw technologyHere the trunk of the Christmas tree is placed in the central opening. Then this is fixed with three to four wing screws (depending on the model). The screws are drilled laterally into the trunk one after the other.

nice look

good durability

x high weight of the stand

x at least two people are required for the construction

x Complicated structure - a lot of readjustment necessary

x unsuitable for very thick logs

Clamping technologyWith this technique, the clamps are pushed apart by means of a foot lever. The tree is then positioned vertically in the stand on a mandrel. Then the clamps are fixed with the lever so that the tree is fixed. To open the Christmas tree stand, the lever is operated again.

relatively easy and quick assembly

can be set up by one person alone

lighter weight

x not a particularly secure stand (only secured at certain points)

x Readjusting cumbersome - the Christmas tree stand has to be fully opened every time

Cable technologyThis technique works in a similar way to the clamping technique using a foot lever. Here, however, there is also a wire rope fixed by brackets, which also encloses the tree as a punctual hold and thus gives it more support.

relatively easy and quick assembly

can be set up by one person alone

particularly secure stand

lighter weight

Step mechanism ensures safety when opening

x Readjusting more cumbersome

3. Our buying advice: You should pay attention to this when buying a Christmas tree stand

Each category of Christmas tree stands has its own individual advantages and disadvantages. Which Christmas tree stand is best for your four walls, however, depends on several factors and your very individual requirements for the product. However, there are some criteria that you should pay particular attention to when buying.

3.1. The right material

Christmas tree stands are available in many different materials. Especially the already mentioned tree stands made of cast iron or wrought iron usually have a traditional charm and are often optically designed. However, these have the disadvantage that they are particularly heavy. As a result, they are both harder to stow and to transport after the Christmas season.

Wooden Christmas tree stands are also popular. However, they are not suitable for Christmas trees that are set up in the garden or on the terrace and are exposed to a possible downpour there. For outdoor Christmas trees, you should prefer to use Christmas tree stands made of metal, ceramic, brass or steel.

3.2. The tree size

You should also make sure that the stand for the Christmas tree is the right size so that it can offer your tree the best possible stability. You should not underestimate the height of the tree or the weight of a Christmas tree. A Nordmann fir with a height of 2 meters can easily weigh around 10-12 kg. The bigger and heavier the Christmas tree, the bigger and more stable the stand should be. Round tree stands are also generally more stable than, for example, those with a triangular shape.

When choosing a Christmas tree stand for large trees up to 6 meters, you should therefore pay close attention to the manufacturer's information regarding the maximum size and weight of the tree. When in doubt, the following applies: It is better if the Christmas tree stand is a little too big than too small.

In the case of a stand with screw technology, bumps and small branches at the end of the trunk should be milled away by the Christmas tree seller so that the trunk fits into the stand. It may even make sense to take the stand with you when you buy it and have the trunk adjusted for it on site. The disadvantage is that trees absorb water through the bark and this is difficult to do with a milled trunk.

3.3. The water tank for freshness

So that the Christmas tree stays fresh as long as possible and does not start needling too quickly, it should always be supplied with water. There are Christmas tree stands with water containers that you can fill with water after setting up. It is particularly practical if the stand also has a water level indicator. In this way, you always know how much water the tree still has available and when it is time to refill it.

Tip: In order to guarantee even longer freshness, we recommend that you spray the tree with a little water every day!

5. Christmas tree stand in the test: These models are ahead

Do it yourself

Would you like to make a Christmas tree stand yourself? No problem! With a little skill, the right instructions and the right materials, you can also build a Christmas tree stand yourself. As a suggestion, you will find simple instructions here.

The Stiftung Warentest has already tested Christmas tree stands twice. In the 12/2003 edition of the Christmas tree stand test, both a model with screw technology and a model with rope tensioning technology were in the lead with the respective test mark of 2.1. The Christmas tree test winners were a wrought iron stand from Heibi and a wooden Christmas tree stand from Krinner. Both models weren't cheap here - the Heibi stand was € 68 and the Krinner stand € 50.

In the 11/2005 test, only Christmas tree stands that were operated with rope tensioning technology were examined in the test. Here, too, a model from the Heibi Christmas tree stand was the test winner. However, the much cheaper products did not do badly either. At the bottom of the list was a Christmas tree stand for € 14, which still got a grade of 3.0.

In a more recent test by Norddeutscher Rundfunk from 2016, even models from the discounter were ahead. For example, a Christmas tree stand from Aldi for € 14.99, which was identical to an Obi Christmas tree stand and cost around € 10 less, performed very well. This shows: whether Christmas tree stands from Lidl or Christmas tree stands from Aldi - the products from the discounter are not necessarily inferior to expensive premium products.

BOCHUMSCHAU says about our comparison winner

Christmas tree stand recommendations:

Since 1996 one of the largest and most far-reaching DIY portals in German. The right environment for advertising in the field of home and garden. We would be happy to inform you about our booking options by email.